Comparing Small Group Plans in Colorado
For an optometry practice in Colorado Springs, structuring health insurance means navigating a unique internal divide: you need coverage that satisfies high-earning associate optometrists (ODs) while remaining affordable for opticians, technicians, and front-desk staff. If you simply pick a standard small group plan off the shelf, you risk either overpaying for a plan your hourly staff cannot afford to use, or under-insuring your clinical providers.
The correct approach relies on matching the financial mechanics of the health insurance market in Colorado—including specific local network configurations in El Paso County and Connect for Health Colorado regulations—with the distinct staffing classes within your clinic.
The defining characteristic of an optometry practice’s workforce is its bifurcated income distribution. On one side, you have the practice owner and associate ODs, who generally prefer robust, broad-network coverage to protect high assets and cover comprehensive care needs. On the other side, you have optometric technicians, opticians, billers, and receptionists. For these crucial team members, a traditional Gold-tier group plan might carry monthly payroll deductions that consume an unsustainable percentage of their take-home pay, even if the practice covers 50% of the premium.
When lower-wage employees waive coverage because their share of the premium is too high, the practice risks failing the insurance carrier’s minimum participation requirement. Most traditional group health plans in Colorado require that 70% of eligible employees (who do not have other valid coverage, like a spouse’s plan or Medicare) enroll in the policy. Falling below this threshold can result in the carrier denying or non-renewing the group policy, leaving the practice owners and associate doctors without coverage.
To solve this, a practice owner must choose a benefit structure that manages costs for the business, clears regulatory hurdles, and delivers usable value to two completely different employee demographics.
In Colorado, any business with 1 to 50 full-time equivalent (FTE) employees purchases coverage in the small group market. Small group plans are guaranteed issue, meaning carriers cannot deny coverage or charge higher premiums based on the medical history of your staff. Premiums are determined entirely by age, tobacco use, and the geographic rating area (El Paso County operates under its own specific rating dynamics within Colorado).
Most group carriers allow a business to offer a “dual option” or “triple option” setup. Instead of forcing everyone into a single plan, the practice owner selects a base plan—often a Bronze or Silver HMO—and agrees to pay a set percentage (e.g., 50% or 75%) of that base plan’s premium.
Employees who want the base plan pay their share out of their paycheck pre-tax. Associate ODs or managers who want a more comprehensive Gold or Platinum PPO can “buy up” to the richer plan, paying the premium difference themselves.
Network design in El Paso County requires careful attention. Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) and Exclusive Provider Organization (EPO) plans dominate the small group and individual markets due to their lower premiums. These plans do not offer out-of-network benefits except in true medical emergencies.
If you select an HMO or EPO for your staff, you must verify that the carrier’s local network includes the facilities your employees actually use. In Colorado Springs, healthcare delivery is heavily consolidated around major systems. A plan that looks affordable on paper is a liability if it completely excludes UCHealth Memorial Hospital or Centura’s Penrose-St. Francis facilities, forcing employees to drive to Denver or Pueblo for in-network specialist care. Always verify a carrier’s provider directory for the specific El Paso County zip codes where your staff live and work.
For an optometry practice struggling with participation rates or the varying needs of doctors versus technicians, an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA) is often the most effective solution.
Instead of purchasing a group policy and dealing with renewals, participation minimums, and carrier negotiations, the practice sets a defined monthly allowance of tax-free money. Employees then use this allowance to purchase their own individual health insurance policies directly through Connect for Health Colorado (the state’s ACA exchange) or off-exchange.
The core advantage of an ICHRA for clinical environments is that you do not have to offer the exact same allowance to everyone. The IRS allows employers to define specific employee classes and offer different benefit amounts to each, provided the classes are legitimate and not designed to discriminate based on health status.
Common compliant classes for an optometry practice include:
Example Scenario: An optometry clinic in Colorado Springs establishes an ICHRA. The practice owner defines two classes: Salaried and Hourly.
Employees take their respective allowances to Connect for Health Colorado. A young technician might choose a Bronze HMO where the $350 allowance covers the entire premium, leaving them with no payroll deduction. An associate doctor might choose a premium Gold plan, applying their $800 allowance and paying the remainder out of pocket.
Because an ICHRA is a reimbursement mechanism and not a traditional group plan, there are no carrier participation requirements. If half of your hourly staff decline the ICHRA because they are on a spouse’s plan, your associate doctors can still utilize their ICHRA allowances without penalty.
| Coverage Strategy | Cost Control for Practice | Participation Requirement | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Small Group | Fixed percentage of premium; subject to annual carrier rate hikes. | Usually 70-75% of eligible employees. | Practices with highly cohesive staff who want traditional, seamless benefits. |
| ICHRA | Highly predictable; practice sets the exact dollar allowance. | None. Employees buy individual plans. | Practices with distinct divides between OD and hourly staff needs. |
| QSEHRA | Predictable, but subject to strict IRS maximum annual caps. | None. | Practices with fewer than 50 FTEs that do not want to define separate employee classes. |
A Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSEHRA) functions similarly to an ICHRA but is exclusively for businesses with fewer than 50 employees that do not offer a group health plan.
While an ICHRA allows for different allowance amounts based on employee classes, a QSEHRA requires that all eligible full-time employees receive the same allowance (though it can vary by family size). Furthermore, QSEHRAs have strict annual contribution limits set by the IRS, whereas ICHRAs have no contribution caps. For an optometry practice that wants to offer identical, equitable benefits to an associate doctor and a receptionist, a QSEHRA is a straightforward, low-administrative-burden tool.
If your optometry practice uses a traditional small group plan, ensure you have a Section 125 Premium Only Plan (POP) document in place. This IRS provision is what legally allows you to deduct the employee’s portion of the health insurance premium from their paycheck before payroll taxes are applied.
Without a Section 125 plan, employees would pay their premiums with after-tax dollars, and the practice would owe FICA taxes on that money. A Section 125 plan effectively lowers the employee’s taxable income and saves the practice approximately 7.65% in payroll taxes on the deducted amounts. This is a foundational piece of any group benefits package and should never be overlooked when setting up a new group policy.
Colorado has implemented several state-level healthcare reforms that directly impact how health plans operate, both in the small group market and on the individual exchange (relevant if you use an ICHRA).
Passed by the state legislature, the Colorado Option requires insurance carriers to offer standardized health plans designed to lower out-of-pocket costs and reduce systemic premiums. These plans must cover primary care visits, mental health visits, and certain other high-value services with predictable, fixed copays before the deductible is met.
For your staff, a Colorado Option plan means they do not have to pay the full contracted rate for a doctor’s visit while trying to satisfy a $4,000 deductible. They simply pay the stated copay from day one. When evaluating small group plans or guiding employees through an ICHRA, identifying Colorado Option plans can drastically improve how hourly staff experience their coverage.
If you do not offer group insurance, or if you offer an ICHRA, your employees will likely purchase coverage on Connect for Health Colorado. The ACA provides Advance Premium Tax Credits (APTC) to lower the cost of individual insurance for those who qualify based on household income.
Recently, federal rules fixed the “family glitch.” Previously, if an employer offered affordable coverage strictly for the employee, the employee’s spouse and children were locked out of marketplace subsidies, even if the employer’s family coverage was prohibitively expensive. Now, affordability is tested separately for the employee and the family. If the premium to add dependents to your practice’s small group plan exceeds a set percentage of the employee’s household income, the dependents may waive the employer plan and receive heavy subsidies on Connect for Health Colorado, saving the family thousands of dollars annually.
If your optometry practice is simply you—or you and a partner with no W-2 employees—you do not qualify for small group coverage in Colorado. A small group requires at least one common-law employee who is not a spouse of the owner.
In this scenario, practice owners must purchase coverage on the individual market. Connect for Health Colorado allows individuals to enroll during the annual Open Enrollment Period (November 1 through January 15) or during a Special Enrollment Period triggered by a qualifying life event, such as losing previous coverage, moving, or having a child.
Premiums paid for individual health insurance by a self-employed individual can often be deducted on your federal tax return, lowering your adjusted gross income, provided you have a net profit for the year and are not eligible to participate in a subsidized health plan maintained by another employer (such as a spouse’s employer).
To determine the optimal setup for your Colorado Springs practice, evaluate your workforce through this logical sequence:
Implementing health insurance requires balancing the clinical reality of an optometry practice against the specific mechanics of the Colorado insurance market. Make the decision based on participation realities and budget sustainability, ensuring your benefits serve both your retention goals and your bottom line.
Compare small group plans, ICHRAs, and network options specifically for your staff in Colorado Springs.
Get a Free Consultation